25 May 2008

See, the part I don't understand...

Is how getting involved, or even sympathising with the Big Circle Boys can be perceived as the classier move...

The frustration on Toronto police Insp. Peter Yuen's face was unmistakable as he addressed the Chinese community two weeks after a hard-working father of two was killed by a stray bullet in east Chinatown.

Two weeks had gone by and police had not received a single tip, he told reporters at a news conference.

"We have yet to receive a single phone call from this community," he said. The January shooting remains unsolved to this day.
And before... yet again... we start into how our racist Canadian system discriminates against non-whites... let's examine that Asian "class" thing...
Karen Sun, the executive director of the Toronto chapter of the Chinese Canadian National Council, said for some parents, becoming a police officer is as prestigious a job as becoming a plumber.

"It's a class issue," she said. "Not that policing is bad but we want our children to have good professional jobs. Policing is seen more as being a lower status kind of job."
Of course, that's not the fallacious "hot-button argument" that's inevitably offered up first...
The police have a less than honourable reputation in China. The stereotype is that the profession tends to attract people who are uneducated and unmotivated to move past their working class stature.

Moreover, police officers are often seen as being corrupt, taking advantage of a stringent regime to exert excessive power over the people.
Hang on a second... if that's an accurate perception of the mindset within "the community"... wouldn't that logically throw suspicion on the motives of every Chinese recruit on the police force?

Whaddaya call that? Oh, c'mon... the word is right there on the tip of my tongue...

P.S. -- Any Chinese readers out there... who care to weigh in here?

*


4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hang on a second... if that's an accurate perception of the mindset within "the community"... wouldn't that logically throw suspicion on the motives of every Chinese recruit on the police force?
Ummm...gotta call this one a bit far fetched (respectfully of course!) Asian Canadians who have "assimilated" do not view police in that manner, and as such if they choose a career in law enforcement are not looking to be corrupt.
You are kinda implying that any asian police officer is suspect...or am I reading too much into that?

Neo Conservative said...

*
"anon asks... You are kinda implying that any asian police officer is suspect..."

no... i'm not... but thanks for asking for clarification, instead of simply screaming about nazis & racism... like the underclass of leftbot trolls i often get here.

if you reread what i actually wrote... i label it 'a fallacious "hot-button argument"' AND refer specifically to 'the mindset within "the (chinese) community"'... which is how this is being portrayed in the piece at ctv.ca.
ctv is saying... and talk about sweeping generalisations... the community automatically assumes all cops are corrupt and that's why they won't talk to them... and they trot out a chinese community spokesperson to pad their assertion.

as far as 'asian canadians who have "assimilated"' goes... doesn't the 'executive director of the toronto chapter of the chinese canadian national council' count as assimilated? i mean, she's the one attempting to rationalise the lower class corrupt cop argument.

i'm simply attempting to break out what the people within the community, according to this ctv puff piece anyway, are saying.

any clearer now?

*

Anonymous said...

but thanks for asking for clarification - I try not to jump to conclusions, and I sure as hell ain't no leftbot :)

Now that I reread (and again for good measure) you post, I get your point (sorry I tend to scan).

doesn't the 'executive director of the toronto chapter of the chinese canadian national council' count as assimilated? - No she does not. If she were assimilated, she wouldn't be running an ethno-politial group (which probably gets government $$$ but that's another discussion)...she would simply define herself and everyone else as Canadian. Period. No ethnic prefix required. And she would be condemning the residents of the area (regardles of race) for not helping the police instead of explaining it away with a wash of stupid excuses...I mean if you come to Canada for a better life, wouldn't you expect that the police here are better/nicer/less corrupt than whereever it is you come from?

If we are to have (and fund) orgs like hers, shouldn't she (and leaders of other "ethnic" orgs) be the first ones on the news telling people to help out? to trust the police, to assimilate...

Naw...I guess I am too naieve...

langmann said...

Best officer I ever met was a Chinese guy about 5'5" tall with hutzpah the size of an elephant. Stood up to some 6'+ tall oaf who had been harassing women at a place I used to work. The oaf tried to intimidate the officer but he stood his ground and before you knew it the idiot had his hands cuffed.

But your point is well made about CTV et al. This is why I don't watch the "News" anymore.